Disclosure Management: Comparing Compliance Solutions

Upgrading from a manual disclosure management process leads to accurate, up-to-date insights and risk visibility

Compliance disclosures are a critical element of an organization’s compliance and ethics management program. The organization requires structured approaches to managing disclosures such as conflicts of interest, and a way to address compliance related forms and processing for gifts, entertainment, and travel or facilitated payments. This requires the ability to intake information, route it for review and approval or denial, document exceptions, and provide a strong defensible system of record of the entire process.

The traditional approach to disclosure management has been manual processes involving print or electronic forms that thread compliance disclosures, like conflicts of interest, through time-consuming manual processes where things often get missed, slip through cracks, or mistakes are made. Manual processes or older software treat disclosures as static entities, making it difficult, if not impossible, for employees to access or update previously filed disclosures. This results in static disclosures that are filed and forgotten, rather than living documents that contain accurate, up-to-date insight into relationships and their potential impact on the business.

The next phase of disclosure management

There is a growing demand for compliance disclosure management solutions that can be more dynamically managed to address Conflicts of Interest; Gifts, Entertainment and Hospitality; Political Contributions; and other areas of compliance disclosure.

While there are several dozen solutions available in the market that do Compliance Disclosure Management, they are not all created equal. One differentiator is the focus. Some are purpose-built for a specific disclosure area such as Conflicts of Interest, and don’t address a range of other compliance disclosure areas. Others are broad disclosure platforms that are highly agile, where the organization can adapt fields and customize forms, workflow, tasks, and reporting to meet a range of compliance disclosure areas. Some compliance disclosure solutions operate as a module in a broader compliance management platform, where disclosures can be managed and cross-referenced to policies, training, regulations, risks, assessments, and cases.

In my evaluation of Compliance Disclosure Management solutions in the market, I separate basic and competitive solutions, but then also distinguish advanced capabilities that separate competitive solutions from each other.

  • Basic compliance disclosure management solutions: These are solutions, and there are many of them, that address the basic forms, workflow, and task management of compliance disclosures management with some basic reporting capabilities. They can present a disclosure form, capture attestations, and route the form through a workflow for review and approval/denial. Most often, but not always, they focus on a single compliance disclosure area such as Conflicts of Interest.
  • Competitive compliance disclosure solutions: These are the solutions that most often come up in competitive situations, and have stronger capabilities to manage a breadth of compliance disclosures in the organization. They have more advanced reporting capabilities and provide a stronger portal for the configuration and customization of disclosures. Some key capabilities of competitive solutions are:
    • The ability to manage a breadth of disclosure types
    • Configurable and adaptable to organizations’ specific needs down to the field and value level
    • Strong graphical workflow builder and task management that allows for parallel as well as linear workflows
    • The breadth of templates for forms and reports on disclosures
    • Strong dashboard and reporting engine with pre-built reports as well as the ability to do custom reports
    • The ability to present the relevant policy, gather attestation to the policy and provide the training with the disclosure
    • Provide for regularly scheduled/periodic disclosure campaigns, as well as the ad hoc/triggered disclosures when they arise
    • Ability to manage and document disclosures that are exceptions/exemptions to the defined policy, and regularly track and monitor them
    • Provide a robust and legally defensible audit trail/system of record of disclosure related activities
    • Allow for attachments, such as documents/evidence, to disclosures

More advanced capabilities in disclosure management include:

  • Disclosure forms and workflow that are highly configurable by the average business user (e.g., citizen developer) without extensive IT knowledge
  • Advanced workflow based on disclosure type and role (e.g, hierarchical workflows)
  • Integration with other business systems, such as HR management systems, to populate information and provide information consistency between systems, or to integrate with ERP systems to pull up transaction history for disclosures related to gifts and entertainment to a particular entity in the past
  • Advanced reporting capabilities, including regulatory reporting in which reports are automatically generated in the format specific regulators are looking for (e.g., securities industry reporting for COI)
  • The ability to define and manage disclosure campaigns to broad and specific employee audiences
  • Integration with policy and training so the disclosure form also includes the written policy as well as training on the policy
  • The ability to provide anonymous reporting on issues related to compliance disclosure
  • Risk management capabilities to measure risk and track key risk indicators (KRIs) related to disclosures
  • Mobile interface/application where disclosures can be reported on smartphones and tablets
  • Collaborative engagement that allows disclosure reviewers and disclosures to communicate and interact back and forth to ask questions and provide more information
  • The ability to provide confidential notes that are encrypted and protected by the disclosure reviewer(s)
  • Provide for follow-up tasks and action items that may be scheduled out in advance to follow-up on disclosures that were approved but needs closer monitoring or other activities

Whether you are looking for a basic or advanced solution, one key requirement to consider across these areas is the user experience. You need a solution that employees will use and not find burdensome.

From the Convercent team:

Ready to find a Disclosures management solution tailored to your specific needs? We’re here to help. Get in touch via the form below to chat about defining your needs or see our Disclosures solution in action.

Speak with our team